Our wine, beer, and spirits shop is open daily from the moment we unlock the doors until close— with liquor sales available until 9 p.m. (it's the Wisconsin way, don'tcha know). Whether you're looking for a perfect pairing, a rare find, or a go-to favorite, we're here to help you drink better.
Retail pricing for carryout only. Bottle Shop items enjoyed in the restaurant incur an additional In-House Opening & Service Fee.
Elevate your wine experience with a Story Hill BKC Wine Club membership. Each month, our expert team hand-selects two exceptional bottles—ranging from rare finds to standout selections from both New and Old World producers—so you can enjoy better wine, both here and at home.
Our team—chefs, co-owners, and beverage experts—personally taste-tests and selects exceptional single barrel bourbons and spirits, chosen for their character both neat and in cocktails. Ask your server or bartender about our current selections during your next visit to Story Hill BKC, but act fast—these limited releases go quickly!
Our wine selection is thoughtfully curated with value in mind, ensuring there's always something to love. Recognized by Wine Spectator with a Best of Award of Excellence in 2026, we're here to help you find the perfect bottle. Wines purchased in the shop and enjoyed in the restaurant incur an additional In-House Opening & Service Fee.
Looking for an easy, meaningful gift around events or seasonal celebrations? A curated bottle, Wine Club membership, or limited-release spirit from Story Hill BKC makes a thoughtful choice for game days, holidays, birthdays, and special occasions throughout the year.
Since earning our first Wine Spectator Award of Excellence in 2015, we've continued to refine and expand our wine program. In 2020, we achieved the prestigious Best of Award of Excellence—the distinction with two wine glasses on the certificate—and have proudly held it through 2024. This honor was awarded to just 11 restaurants in Wisconsin and only four in Milwaukee, recognizing wine lists that offer exceptional selections, thoughtfully paired with cuisine, and appealing to a wide range of wine lovers. Over the years, we've been celebrated as a cozy, welcoming spot where a restaurant and wine shop come together over shareable plates and unforgettable bottles.
